Yahoo made a top ten list of the worst science in movies with scientific themes and Indiana Jones and the Crystal Skull was number 10 (the worst because they start at number one and count up). This is mostly based on the atomic bomb scene more than unlikely aliens, but I’m still happy.
http://movies.yahoo.com/photos/collections/gallery/903/top-10-scientific-inaccurate-movies#photo10
I had a post elsewhere on the web, reprinted here, listing several reasons why I hated that movie. Hate. Hate. Hate.
THE NEW INDIANA JONES MOVIE WAS THE WORST MOVIE EVER MADE
(originally written Sunday, June 22, 2008)
To anyone reading this: if you enjoyed that movie then I hate you.
Here is a nice list of things in (mostly) chronological order that pissed me off about that movie:
1. CGI groundhogs are stupid and useless. Use real groundhogs.
2. Opening does not fill me with a sense of wonder of exotic places.
3. Cruising teenagers vs. military. Dumb scene and pointless. Why were the kids out there in the first place and where did they go when the atomic bomb went off?
4. Area 51? You’ve got to be kidding me. Lame.
5. Russians make poor substitutes for Nazis.
5. Magnetism doesn’t work that way.
6. So-called homage to Raiders is actually a message that the first three movies should be forgotten. I hate.
7. Where are all the other super refridgerators that can survive atomic bombs?
8. Forced iconic imagery (of Indy and an Atomic Bomb) because the story doesn’t matter, only visual effects.
9. CIA hadn’t been invented yet. Why is an aging archeologist in the CIA anyway?
10. Fuck that kid from Transformers.
11. Exposition never felt like exposition in the other movies.
12. Crystal Skulls, mental telepathy, government conspiracies. Retarded.
13. The commies are after you so you fly to Cuba first? In 1957? Brilliant.
14. Who are the skull mask warriors? Where did they come from and where did they go?
15. Just carve open archeological finds for no reason, especially the body of a Conquistador. Nice field work, Jones. Oh, one was open already? Woops! I guess we carved that other one up for no reason!
16. ALIEN FUCKING SKULL!
17. More mind control powers, crystal skulls, and pseudo-science TRUTH bullshit.
18. They blow up the road making machine first. How the hell do they drive through the rainforest now? Wouldn’t it be easier to go on foot?
19. CGI monkeys. See my first note. And monkeys would KILL YOU. This is another dig from the pseudo-scientists against evolution. Because as pseudo-scientists know, science, anthropology, and archeology is always wrong. Thank you for making Indiana Jones’s life work illigitimate again.
20. Tarzan. This is the closest thing we get to Indiana Jones using his bullwhip for the rest of the movie. Sad.
21. Fencing is important to me. I’ll let people enjoy movie-style sword fighting but in light of the other crap I felt inclined to bitch about this too. Sword fighting involves some footwork, moving around, and would be nigh-impossible on a moving jeep. Oh, and I’m supposed to believe this drop-out who took a couple of fencing classes can hold his own against a trained sword fighter and seasoned killer?
22. Ancient culture still alive and well in the amazon. That I can deal with. They just didn’t seem as threatening as the warriors at the beginning of Raiders. And flying rocks and bolos are deadlier than CGI ants.
23. How did the Conquistador thieves leave things the way they were before they got there? Why didn’t they steal gold and artifacts from the alien archeologists? How do you steal a skull from a room that needs a skull to get into it?
24. Fuck space aliens and their granted knowledge. As though early humans couldn’t figure out farming and irrigation. And also thank you for the idea that knowledge can only be gained spiritually. Idiots.
25. Super magnet telepathic skull would pretty much stay where it is when Spaniards yanked on it. Wouldn’t they be able to melt their brains like they did the commie chick with the fluctuating accent?
I also forgot to mention the most important part of suckage in this movie: 13 aliens. Anyone who has heard pseudoscience alien/religion statement can tell you that this refers to the 12 tribes of Israel plus the thirteenth “lost tibe” that would become the Native Americans. A big reoccurring theme among pseudoscientists and an insult to both archeology and religion. In the end, Jesus was an alien. Which also makes the previous THREE MOVIES totally illigitimate, as I suggested with the Arc reference at the beginning of the movie. To remind us all that THAT WAS A RADIO TO TALK TO ALIENS!
26. Ancient civilization still surviving that the aliens helped create is wiped out by the aliens leaving. So the Nazis killed all the warriors. What about women and children? And why would aliens do that if they wanted to give knowledge to humans in the first place? None of this makes sense. And let’s not forget the comment about “erasing the fingerprints of the gods” just to hit us with the Grahm Hancock “theory” of aliens establishing human culture. To hell with all of it.
27. Iconic imagery again of Indy and a spaceship. Fuck you, Spielberg. Fuck you, Lucas.
I’m sure I forgot or blocked some things out. Feel free to remind me.
I can’t watch Raiders now without thinking the arc is a radio to talk to crystal skull aliens that melts Nazis with too much knowledge. And no more kids will be inspired to become archeologists by these movies unless they want to find aliens. Science has again suffered a horrible wound.